Thursday, January 24, 2013

Life by Design: My Thoughts

In Wednesday's post I mentioned that I was invited by Cheryl to attend a dinner with her Life by Design group, and I wanted to elaborate a bit on that. This is my interpretation of what it's all about, so please feel free to correct me if I'm wrong in the comments, Cheryl!


So Life by Design (LBD) is a way of living founded by Dr. Kresimir Jug and Dr. Rachelle Vanderheyden-Jug, who are chiropractors here in London. Essentially it believes that we are all designed to be extraordinary. We are meant to be awesome. We are meant to be happy. We are meant to be healthy. However in today's society, a lot of our lifestyles are contrary to this. We have higher rates of chronic disease than ever and we're struggling with high rates of anxiety and depression too. But instead of dealing with the root cause, we just turn to doctors to "fix" us with prescriptions.  We're not healthy or happy because we're not living our lives by design.

The beliefs of LBD rest on the four pillars of Eat by Design, Move by Design, Think by Design, and Power by Design, which I'll explain here.

EAT.  LBD believes in eating whole foods - foods that occur naturally and are the foods that don't have labels at the grocery store. This I agree with for the most part. The most nutritious foods are definitely unprocessed fruits, vegetables, grains, meats and dairy. However, does that mean my pantry is empty? No. I have lots of packaged cereals, pastas, and condiments in there because I believe they can be part of a healthy diet too.

LBD also believes in eating lots of animal protein. Personally I can't say I've ever jumped on the protein obsession that seems to have rocked the world lately. Yes, protein is important. Yes, the Recommended Daily Allowance for protein may be too low (I just recently read a paper about how it might be increased). But does that mean we need to be eating half a cow at every meal? Personally, I don't think so. I think plant protein has a lot of nutritional merit too - it's low in fat, high in fibre, and usually high in lots of vitamins and minerals too*. So I don't think it should be discredited.

This is the meal of salad and salmon with veggies that we were served at the Life By Design dinner.

The last eating "rule" that LBD believes in is cutting out grains, legumes, and dairy (but dairy is a gray area). And this is where they lost me. I believe the healthiest diet is one that includes all food groups, provided you have no intolerances or allergies. At the dinner they mentioned that grains have no nutritional value. False. Whole grains are an excellent source of fibre, manganese, selenium, phosphorus, zinc and B vitamins*. They also said that when you eat grains, they leach out nutrients from your body... I can't say I've ever heard of that happening in my 6 years of studying science and nutrition. I'm curious as to what science they're using to back up that statement because until I see it, I don't believe it.

One of my other qualms with this way of eating is that I don't like to treat food purely as fuel. Obviously as a future RD I think eating healthily is extremely important. But the foodie in me believes that food should be fun, delicious, and pleasureful too - and that means enjoying ice cream and pizza on occasion!

So while I definitely think they have some valid points in their philosophy about eating, I think there are some flaws as well. Eating lots of whole foods is great, but you certainly won't see me ditching grains, legumes and dairy anytime soon.

*Based on the nutrient analysis of these foods from the Canadian Nutrient File.

MOVE. I found myself nodding in agreement to everything they said about Move by Design. First of all, they recommend just moving period. Our bodies are made to move. We have limbs, joints, tendons, etc that allow us to move and we should use them.

Source

Second, they think we should lift heavy. I don't think everyone has to start a super intense weight lifting regimen or join CrossFit, but we should be able to carry out every day tasks like lifting a suitcase into your car trunk or taking a box down from a shelf. And since none of our daily lives involve lifting boxes all day, we need to get in that conditioning through some sort of planned weight workouts. Third, LBD believes we should move fast. Agreed. Aerobic fitness is one of the pillars of fitness and it's really important to our heart health!

THINK. This is my favourite aspect of LBD. As I already said, one of their primary beliefs is that we are designed to be extraordinary. So that's how we should think. We need to start believing in the awesomeness of ourselves and stop doubting our abilities. Because as cheesy as it is, the saying that "You can do anything if you put your mind to it" is 100% true! And on that note, LBD also believes that we need to put our minds to something. We need to have a purpose to anchor our lives.

Source

POWER. This one I didn't quite understand. Dr. K is a chiropractor, so he believes that our spines and nerves need to be functioning properly in order for us to function properly. I know zilch about chiropractics, so I can't really form an opinion on this. I'd love to hear some comments from anyone who knows more about the subject though!

Overall, what I liked most about LBD was the Thinking by Design aspect. It really inspired me and I feel like I left the dinner with a slightly different perspective on life.

What do you think of Life by Design? What do you most agree with? Disagree with?

Note: This post is not meant to offend anyone or their chosen lifestyles. These are merely my personal opinions!

16 comments:

  1. I've never heard of Life By Design, it sounds interesting!

    From how you describe it is does seem to have some merits (being positive/purposeful, exercising, emphasizing whole foods) but I tend to give anything that tells me to cut out a food group the side eye. Why does everyone want me to give up oatmeal and cereal? It's not happening for me!

    To me, it looks Crossfit and Paleo-ish - kind of like they're just jumping on the exercise/diet trends of the moment.

    ReplyDelete
  2. this is so interesting to read and your taste on it. I can't wait to see what kind work you do with this. It seems like something you can incorporate into your life, maybe not fully but definitely a lot of it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like the idea of believing and living an extraordinary life and that they believe in moving and eating whole foods but i agree with you about the grains...and sam's comment made me nod in agreement and smile...it does sound similar to those things

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like your critique, it raises many valid points!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved to hear your take on this!! We share exactly the same opinion on the "eat" part - the science behind the paleo diet is EXTREMELY flawed. No, paleolithic humans did not eat grains, but does this mean that the domestication of plants was a detriment to human health? clearly, since our planet now consists of 8 billion people, grains are a good thing - domestic crops are what allowed us to thrive as a species. Also, EVOLUTION happens and we CAN tolerate them. Well, most people can. I can't tolerate grains with gluten in them but you better believe I eat quinoa, farro, millet, wild rice, black rice, brown rice, white rice, processed GF cereals and breads.....
    ....because they friggin taste good and you need to feed your SOUL as well as your BODY.

    As for the Move part, I agree with the vague principles but I don't think Crossfit really is the be-all-end-all of fitness that crossfit junkies see it as. I might be biased as an endurance athlete but I'm also a future exercise physiologist so I know my shit with this stuff too (mostly) and crossfit doesn't solve all the body's mechanical problems...and can create some itself.

    As for power - I do see a chiropractor regularly and I have to say it's done me a lot of good. They are right that when your spine is misaligned, other things start to go wrong, and you might not notice it in every day life, but if you're an endurance athlete it can certainly mess you up and lead to compensation injuries. I happen to have a very fluid spine and pelvis. This made me a very talented ballerina back when that was my thing, but it means that my spinal joints and pelvis shift out of place quite easily - which as a distance runner is no good. Cheryl calls it "getting your power turned on" but the clinical term is a "chiropractic adjustment" - basically what it does is puts your spine and pelvis in the correct place. It's not important for everyone, because not everyone's spine/pelvis moves around as much as mine, but if you're like me then you definitely feel stronger and more comfortable/more stable after you've been "adjusted".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. oh and I forgot to add...chiropractic adjustment (for me and my specific fluidity issues) just feels like a more deliberate, careful version of cracking your own back :-)

      Delete
  6. Can I just so how refreshing it is to hear this! It's like everyone's afraid to talk about how healthy whole grain foods are for you! And they are. I really don't get the whole paleo thing to be honest. All that meat eating, hmm. I mean I guess whatever works for you, but I don't get how it can help digestion, increase health, clear skin and all of that. Or what makes it the new "phase". Not trying to judge, I guess I just don't understand the hype haha. Maybe I should read more about it or something. I completely agree on all of your thoughts here! Especially including ALL food groups, of course except for ethical reasons/allergies. People have gave me a hard time recently about my intolerances, but I'm not sure what's right. People are saying intolerances aren't "real", but um they certainly feel real to me haha. Very great points you made! I just loved this. I definitely like the think part of LBD!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Really great review, Chelsea. I had never heard of Life by Design, but I pretty much share your thoughts down to a T so I guess I would have a similar opinion of them as you do. I really do like the idea of believing in ourselves and not setting ourselves up for failure by automatically assuming that we can't do something, but I'm definitely not down with the eating part of their philosophy. From personal experience, I know that I feel absolutely wretched if I don't eat enough grains. A diet that's too high in fat and protein not only messes with my stomach big time, but leaves me feeling lethargic and moody. I think that trying to prescribe one overarching diet for everyone is a big mistake because we're all so different, and what works for one person isn't going to work for another.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The pseudoscience behind the Paleo/meat-eating diets really disturbs me. As you rightly point out, I have no idea how anyone gets away with suggesting that grains have no nutritional value when there is no evidence to support that claim and plenty of evidence to the contrary.

    I just wonder if decades down the line there aren't going to be a huge amount of kidney and heart problems from eating so much meat, eggs and 'healthy' fats to excessive levels (the amount of coconut oil involved sometimes makes me squirm).

    Good for you for keeping your own opinions and not being 'brainwashed.'

    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for your honest review, Chelsea- it’s refreshing ☺! Life By Design sounds interesting although I don’t agree with the bit about eliminating food groups….at least not as a universal must! I know some people thrive on Paleo but personally, I need my grains & dairy both for taste and satiety! Life without ice cream, cheese or oats would just be sad ;)! Also as for the bit about animal protein, I don’t think it’s the “be all end all”. I do eat animal protein but also eat plenty of vegetarian protein. I don’t think one is better than the other so long as you eating enough of it!

    ReplyDelete
  10. What a neat concept! I've never heard of live by design before but I have to agree with a lot of their views. I think staying active and lifting heavy are two key components to living a healthy lifestyle and also really agree with the eating whole foods approach!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Chelsea It was great having you on Tuesday night, and I'm glad that I was able to provide you with some information that inspired thought and a blog post. It seems like grains and research are the themes to most peoples comments. A couple questions to ask yourself

    1) What do I get from grains that I can't get from vegetables?
    2) Is it an issue to my digestion that every grain has to be processed in order for me to eat it?

    As for research here is a link to many resources where you can find many different articles:

    http://www.proteinpower.com/journals.htm

    If you are interested in more specific information that supports what I talked about you can use the following:

    http://whole9life.com/

    http://robbwolf.com/

    I'll invite any questions and comments, also not sure how many of you are UWO students but I could potentially be speaking at the research symposium, would be nice to meet some of you.

    Dr. K

    kresimirjugdc@yahoo.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. I like this. Eating whole foods is definitely the best. I'm a little skeptical about the no-grain thing too. A lot of programs recommend cutting them out, but if they are nutritious and you aren't allergic, I don't really see the point. Interesting that they advise you to lift heavy, but I definitely like it!

    ReplyDelete
  13. YES for eating whole foods!!!!!! i really do believe that eating a healthy diet can relieve so many ailments and diseases!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I had never really looked into it until now. I am in agreement with you in the food area. I do not agree with cutting out any major food groups and while yes you can get CHO from other sources grains are a huge part a healthy diet that has variety. And I also agree with the fact that food is more than fuel, it brings people together and is part of culture. But I love what you say about move and about strength/lifting I take pride in my ability to lift my own suitcase. I may be small but I can do things on my own and that makes me independent. Thanks for this review girl it is really awesome!

    ReplyDelete
  15. I really enjoyed your honest and in-depth review of Life By Design, Chelsea! I couldn't agree more about grains--they can most definitely be part of a healthy lifestyle! Humans have thrived on grains for years; it's only recently (i.e. the past 100 years or so) that highly processed grains have created problems for our society. *Whole* grains provide not only nutrients, but variety to our diets. As for those processed grains? I certainly think they have a place, too. It's all about balance, moderation, and feeding both the body AND the soul. Sometimes my soul wants a treat. :)

    The other components of LBD sound fantastic; I love that organizations like this are encouraging people to be their best selves, and teaching that every facet of health is truly attainable.

    I hope you had a wonderful weekend! <3 xoxo

    ReplyDelete